Legislation Details

File #: HIST-16120    Version: 1 Subject:
Type: Historical Status: Action Item
In control: PARKS, RECREATION AND COMMUNITY SERVICES COMMISSION
On agenda: 3/1/2011 Final action: 3/1/2011
Title: Report from the Recreational Activities and Special Projects Subcommittee and Consideration of the Recommendations of the Dog Park Ordinance Review Group.
Attachments: 1. Report from the Recreational Activities and Specia - ActionItem3.docx, 2. Report from the Recreational Activities and Specia - A3Attachment.pdf
City of Culver City, California Agenda Item Report Meeting Date: 03/01/11 Item Number: A-3__ PRCS COMMISSION AGENDA ITEM: Report from the Recreational Activities and Special Projects Subcommittee and Consideration of the Recommendations of the Dog Park Ordinance Review Group. Contact Person/Dept.: Pam Robinson, Acting PRCS Director Phone Number: (310) 253-6724 Fiscal Impact: Yes [] No [X] General Fund: Yes [] No [] Public Hearing: [] Action Item: [X] Attachments: [X] Public Notification: (Email) Meetings and Agendas – Parks, Recreation and Community Services Commission (02/24/11). Department Approval: Pam Robinson (02/21/11). City Attorney Approval: N/A Fiscal Impact Approval: N/A City Manager Approval: N/A RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends the Parks, Recreation and Community Services (PRCS) Commission receive a report from the Recreational Activities and Special Projects Subcommittee on the recommendations of the Dog Park Ordinance Review Group (DPORG), consider DPORG’s recommendations and take action as deemed appropriate. BACKGROUND: On February 17, 2011 the members of the Dog Park Ordinance Review Group (DPORG) held their second meeting related to the Ordinance review. The primary objective of the group is to determine whether or not the Rules and Regulations for the Culver City Dog Park (the Boneyard), as stated in Culver City Municipal Code Section 9.10.400 (Attachment A), need revision now that the Dog Park has been in operation for almost seven years. The DPORG is not a City committee, but instead is a work group that includes two PRCS Administrative Division staff members, a representative from the City Attorney’s office, two representatives from the Friends of the Culver City Dog Park and the members of the PRCS Commission Recreational Activities and Special Projects Subcommittee, Chair Hudson and Commission Kim. DISCUSSION: At the first meeting of DPORG, two main concerns regarding public participation at the Dog Park were raised: (1) Potential dog-on-dog aggression related to the presence of intact male dogs, and (2) potential problems related to children’s behavior in the Park. In advance of the second meeting of the DPORG, a packet of information was emailed to members in order to inform the discussion on February City of Culver City, California Agenda Item Report 17 (Attachment B). The packet contains information regarding the Los Angeles County Spay/Neuter requirements and a Review of Dog Park Rules of forty-six (46) cities/areas. Intact Male Dogs The Review of Dog Park Rules revealed that while only 9% of the rules specifically stated that dogs must be altered (spayed/neutered) to enter the dog park, 85% stated the only licensed dogs are allowed in the park. In Culver City and other areas, a dog must be altered to be licensed. Therefore, staff collected information regarding the licensing requirements of nearby areas and found that the following included mandatory spay/neuter: City of Los Angeles (covering or partially covering 128 zip code areas), including: • Bel Air • Beverly Hills (the City of LA handles their animal licensing) • Brentwood • Century City • Hollywood • Pacific Palisades • Playa del Rey • Venice • Westchester • Westwood All unincorporated areas of Los Angeles County, including: • Baldwin Hills • Ladera Heights • Marina Del Rey The City of Inglewood In addition, these Cities do not require spay/neuter as part of their dog licensing program but offer a discounted license fee to owners with altered dogs: • Manhattan Beach – $18 altered / $50 unaltered • Redondo Beach – $20 altered / $40 unaltered • Santa Monica – $16.30 altered / $54.70 unaltered After discussing this and other information, the DPORG determined that the most effective and efficient way to address potential problems related to the aggressive behavior associated with many intact male dogs is to: 1) continue to rely on the City of Culver City, California Agenda Item Report existing regulations, which prohibit aggressive dogs in the Park and require all dogs that use the Park to be licensed; and 2) post additional signage at the Dog Park highlighting the rule that a dog must be licensed to use the Park and providing further detail regarding Culver City’s licensing requirement, particularly the fact that it includes mandatory spay/neuter. A draft of a sign that was developed based on this recommendation is included as Attachment C; the actual sign will be 11” wide by 17” high. The Behavior of Children at the Dog Park The Review of Dog Park Rules indicated that 61% of the rules specified that children must be supervised by adults while in the dog park. Language prohibiting children of was found in 28% of the rules. When reviewing the rules, staff found that it is common among cities to have both a formal set of rules, such as those that might be contained in a City Ordinance, and set of behavioral rules or “Rules of Etiquette” that apply to dog parks. Since the existing Culver City Dog Park Rules and Regulations clearly states that “Children twelve (12) years of age and under are not permitted in the Dog Park, unless accompanied and supervised by an adult at all times” (Section 9.10.400-B), the DPORG determined that the most effective and efficient way to address any potential problems related to children’s behavior at the Park is to post additional signage at the park which highlights the existing regulation, explains what “supervision” means for parents and describes the ways children and the adults who accompany them are expected to behave in the Park. A draft of a sign that was developed based on this recommendation is included as Attachment D; the actual sign will be 11” wide by 17” high. Summary In summary, the DPORG recommends that both the concerns regarding intact dogs and the behavior of children be addressed through additional signage at the Dog Park. The presence of such signage will assist participants in “self-policing” the Park to deter unwanted behavior and enhance user experiences at the Park. It should be noted that both draft signs (Attachments C and D) are open to review and discussion by the full Commission. DPORG recommends a three month trial period for the temporary signage, commencing when the Dog Park reopens. At the end of three months, the DPORG will meet to discuss how the signs have been received at the Park, if this solution has adequately addressed the concerns and whether or not the language on the sign should be revised in any way. Once the language on the signs has been finalized, permanent signage will be installed at the Dog Park. The members of the Recreational Activities and Special Projects Subcommittee may want to comment on and/or add to the information presented in this report. City of Culver City, California Agenda Item Report FISCAL ANALYSIS: The fiscal impact associated with temporary signage is minimal and will be absorbed by the PRCS Department budget. When the estimates for the permanent signage are available, staff will contact the Friends of the Culver City Dog Park to inquire as to if they are willing to help cover the cost. ATTACHMENTS: A. Culver City Municipal Code Section 9.10.400: OFF LEASH DOG PARK – RULES AND REGULATIONS B. Information Emailed to the Dog Park Ordinance Review Group on February 15, 2011 C. Draft Sign – Culver City Dog Licensing Requirements (NOTE: The actual sign will be 11” wide by 17” high). D. Draft Sign – Rules of Etiquette for Children and the Adults who Accompany Them to the Culver City Dog Park (NOTE: The actual sign will be 11” wide by 17” high). MOTIONS: That the Parks, Recreation and Community Services Commission: 1. Receive a report from the Recreational Activities and Special Projects Subcommittee; and, 2. Consider the recommendations of the Dog Park Ordinance Review Group; and, 3. Take action as deemed appropriate. MEETING DATE: March 1, 2011 AGENDA ITEM: Report from the Recreational Activities and Special Projects Subcommittee and Consideration of the Recommendations of the Dog Park Ordinance Review Group. ATTACHMENTS Pages A. Culver City Municipal Code Section 9.10.400: OFF LEASH DOG PARK – RULES AND REGULATIONS 1 - 2 B. Information Emailed to the Dog Park Ordinance Review Group on February 15, 2011 3 - 14 C. Draft Sign – Culver City Dog Licensing Requirements (NOTE: Actual sign will be 11” wide by 17” high) 15 D. Draft Sign – Rules of Etiquette for Children and the Adults who Accompany Them to the Culver City Dog Park (NOTE: Actual sign will be 11” wide by 17” high) 16 EXCERPT OF CITY OF CULVER CITY MUNICIPAL CODE CHAPTER 9.10: PARKS, PUBLIC BUILDINGS AND PROPERTY Page 1 of 2 OFF-LEASH DOG PARK § 9.10.400 RULES AND REGULATIONS. Notwithstanding any other provision in this Code, a person may have charge, care, custody or control of any dog in that portion of Culver City Park designated as the Culver City Dog Park (the "Dog Park"), subject to all the following conditions enumerated in this Section. A. The person who has charge, care, custody or control of any dog: 1. Must ensure the dog is currently licensed, vaccinated and over the age of four (4) months, and provide proof of licensing upon request by any City official; 2. Must not allow more than three (3) dogs to be in his or her charge, care, custody or control while in the Dog Park; 3. Must use the appropriate areas of the Dog Park designated for "Small/Timid" or "Large" dogs; 4. Is required to pick-up and dispose of the dog's feces in trash receptacles both in and out of the Dog Park; 5. Must remain with the dog at all times while using the Dog Park, and is solely liable for any and all injuries and/or damage caused by the dog; 6. Shall not permit a dog with a known communicable disease in the Dog Park at any time; 7. Shall not permit a female dog in heat in the Dog Park; 8. Shall not permit an aggressive dog in the Dog Park; 9. Must have the dog restrained by a substantial chain or leash not exceeding six (6) feet in length at all times, except while inside the fenced areas of the Dog Park; and 10. Must remove any pronged or spiked collar or choke collar from the dog prior to entry. B. Children twelve (12) years of age and under are not permitted in the Dog Park, unless accompanied and supervised by an adult at all times. C. No person shall bring a stroller, carriage, baby carrier, bicycle, skateboard, scooter, children's toy, food, dog toy, dog treat or dog food in the Dog Park. ATTACHMENT AEXCERPT OF CITY OF CULVER CITY MUNICIPAL CODE CHAPTER 9.10: PARKS, PUBLIC BUILDINGS AND PROPERTY Page 2 of 2 D. No person shall bring any animal, other than a dog, into the Dog Park. E. 1. No person shall conduct any activity at the Dog Park which may be an immediate danger to the public's health, safety and welfare. 2. Such activity must cease immediately when asked to do so by a City official. F. 1. Smoking is prohibited in the Dog Park. 2. The inhaling, exhaling, burning or carrying of any lighted pipe, cigar, cigarette, weed, plant or other combustible substance in any manner or any form is prohibited. G. No person shall enter or use the Dog Park when it is closed. H. No person shall operate or conduct a business within the Dog Park, unless permitted by the City. I. The use of the Dog Park in the City by an owner of a dog or by a person having charge, care, custody or control of a dog shall constitute an agreement, by said owner or person having charge, care, custody or control of a dog, to protect, indemnify, defend and hold harmless the City from any claim of injury or damage arising from or in connection with the use of the Dog Park, including but not limited to, injuries arising from dog bites. J. 1. A person entering, using or visiting the Dog Park expressly assumes the risk of any injury or damage which may arise from or in connection with such entrance, visit or use of the Dog Park, including but not limited to, injuries resulting from dog bites. 2. The City shall not be liable for injuries or damages arising from or in connection with the use of the Dog Park, including but not limited to, injuries resulting from dog bites, by an owner of a dog or by a person having charge, care, custody or control of a dog. (Ord. No. 2004-015, § 3) § 9.10.405 PENALTIES. Any person who violates or fails to comply with any provision of § 9.10.400 shall be guilty of an infraction, and may be subject to a fine not to exceed $100 per violation. (Ord. No. 2004-015, § 4)   ATTACHMENT A INFORMATION FROM PRCS DEPARTMENT STAFF DATE: 02/15/11 TO: Parks, Recreation and Community Services Commission Chair Hudson and Commissioner Kim; Friends of the Culver City Dog Park Representatives Mr. Peter Vogel and Dr. Dean Gebroe FROM: Patricia Mooney, PRCS Senior Management Analyst THROUGH: Pam Robinson, Acting PRCS Director SUBJECT: Information for the Dog Park Ordinance Review Group The attached documents were requested and are presented for your information: Page(s) Los Angeles County Spay/Neuter Requirements – the City Council amended the Culver City Municipal Code to include these on September 25, 2006 2 - 4 Review of Dog Park Rules Relating to Children and Spaying/Neutering of Dogs – Summary 5 Review of Dog Park Rules Relating to Children and Spaying/Neutering of Dogs – Details 6 - 12 Please note that although it was found that only 9% of the 46 rules reviewed specifically state that dogs must be spayed/neutered, 85% state that only licensed dogs are allowed in the dog park. In Culver City and other areas, a dog must be spayed/neutered to be licensed. Staff is currently researching licensing requirements in surrounding cities to see which ones include mandatory spay/neuter. This information will be sent to the members of the group via email as soon as it is available. Thank you. Attachment B - Page 3 ATTACHMENT BAbout Us Request for Service Shelter Locations Adoptions Lost And Found Pet Licensing Spay & Neuter Pet Vaccinations Laws and Policies Living with Wildlife Pet Owner Info Animal Care Foundation Frequently Asked Questions Jobs/Volunteer Opportunities Enter a search term County Home Home About this Site Online Services Contact Us FAQ Public Info Public Alerts Language Privacy Outreach, Media & Press For the Record IMPORTANT CHANGES TO THE LOS ANGELES COUNTY CODE REGARDING DOGS In an effort to improve public safety and reduce the number of stray dogs overwhelming our animal shelters, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors has passed an ordinance that requires all residents of unincorporated areas in Los Angeles County to have their dogs spayed or neutered and have an identification microchip implanted in each dog. The measure applies to all dogs over the age of four months kept in unincorporated (non- city) areas of Los Angeles County. Contract Cities The following cities have adopted the Spay & Neuter Ordinance: Cities Spay/Neuter This ordinance was passed to promote and protect public safety from the threats presented by stray dogs, as well as to reduce the number of dogs flooding our animal shelters that are subsequently euthanized. Low cost services are available and financial assistance is available to qualified individuals. Unsterilized dogs are creating a crisis in Los Angeles County. Stray dogs are public safety hazards, and unsterilized dogs are more likely to stray. Stray dogs can bite or attack people or other animals, cause traffic accidents, spread disease, damage property and harm the quality of life for residents in a community. During the last fiscal year 23,799 stray dogs were impounded by this department. Unneutered males search for mates and are attracted in packs when female dogs come into heat. One female in heat, even if confined, can make an entire neighborhood unstable by attracting packs of male dogs intent on breeding. These situations often become dangerous. Unsterilized dogs can create unplanned litters, and there are not enough available homes to absorb this surplus. The Los Angeles County Department of Animal Care and Control is overwhelmed with dogs. In Fiscal Year 2004-2005 the department impounded 40,174 dogs, more than any other animal care and control agency in the nation. During that year 18,804 dogs were euthanized. Despite strong efforts to place dogs into new homes and reunite lost dogs with their owners, there are still not enough adoptive homes available. This department is committed to a “no-kill” philosophy. However, in order to reach that goal we must first greatly reduce the numbers of dogs flooding our shelters. This ordinance will help us reach that goal by reducing the number of dogs born or running loose in Los Angeles County. Spaying and neutering also presents many health benefits for dogs. Certain types of cancers in dogs are eliminated by spaying and neutering. Sterilized dogs are less likely to roam and therefore less likely to be lost, hit by a car, injured in a fight, or abused. By spaying or neutering your dog, you are helping solve the problem of pet overpopulation and protecting your dog from potential harm. However, since some dogs cannot be spayed or neutered for certain reasons, this ordinance has exemptions for these cases. These are: Dogs which are unable to be spayed or neutered without a high likelihood of suffering serious bodily harm or death due to age or infirmity. Written confirmation from a licensed veterinarian is required to qualify for this exception. 1. Dogs used by law enforcement agencies for law enforcement purposes. 2. Service or assistance dogs that assist disabled persons. 3. Competition dogs. A Competition Dog is a dog which is used to show, to compete or to breed, which is of a breed recognized by and registered with the American Kennel 4. Page 1 of 3 New Ordinance Introduction Page - Department of Animal Care & Control 2/10/2011 http://animalcare.lacounty.gov/cms1_045463.asp Attachment B - Page 4Club (AKC), United Kennel Club (UKC), American Dog Breeders Association (ADBA) or other approved breed registries. The dog or owner must also meet ONE of the following requirements: The dog has competed in at least one dog show or sporting competition sanctioned by a national registry or approved by the department within the last 365 days; or a. The dog has earned a conformation, obedience, agility, carting, herding, protection, rally, sporting, working or other title from a purebred dog registry referenced above or other registry or dog sport association approved by the department; or b. The owner or custodian of the dog is a member of a department approved purebred dog breed clubs, which maintains and enforces a code of ethics for dog breeding that includes restrictions from breeding dogs with genetic defects and life threatening health problems that commonly threaten the breed. c. If you believe your dog meets one of these exemptions, please complete and return an Exemption Application. Microchips Under this ordinance all dogs must have an identification microchip. Microchip implantation and registration is available to all dog owners FREE of charge thanks to a generous donation from the Found Animal Foundation. You may obtain your free microchip and registration at any Los Angeles County animal shelter. Please call ahead to confirm microchip clinic hours. Microchip Schedules Positive identification that cannot be lost, falsified or altered is essential to reuniting lost pets with their families. Microchipping of animals has become a customary practice – millions of dogs and cats, horses, livestock, birds, wildlife and endangered species are chipped. Microchipping is a simple, non-surgical procedure. The microchip, which is approximately the size of a grain of rice, is injected underneath the skin with a needle. There is no anesthesia required, and even the smallest animals such as fish, puppies and kittens are safely microchipped. Each microchip has a code number embedded in it. When a special, hand-held scanner is passed over the area where the microchip has been implanted, the scanner “reads” the microchip and displays its unique code number. That number is stored in a database that contains the owner contact information. Hundreds of thousands of lost pets have been reunified with their distraught families because the pets were microchipped. While tags can become lost or damaged and tattoos can fade or be altered, microchips provide permanent identification with unique numbers that cannot be changed. Due to the presence of a microchip, this department has reunified owners with pets that had been missing for as long as five years. Low-Cost Assistance Part of this new ordinance includes a $50 voucher program for senior citizens and low- income residents who have a state-issued California Advantage Card. S/N Discount Voucher Request Our agency also has a list of veterinarians who offer low-cost spay and neuter surgeries and accept the vouchers our agency will issue as part of this program. Participating Veterinary Offices We also will conduct low-cost spay and neuter programs for dogs at many of our County shelters and we are working with a wide variety of animal welfare groups who are active in low-cost spay-and-neuter efforts. Ongoing spay/neuter opportunities will be made available, and we encourage you to check our website and with your local County shelter to find out opportunities in your area. In addition, Actors and Others for Animals currently provides FREE spay or neuter services for all Pit Bulls and Rottweilers. Call (818) 755-6045 or (818) 755-6323, or visit their website at www.actorsandothers.com for more information. Effective Date of Enforcement This ordinance became effective on June 1, 2006. The current grace period has been extended until March 1, 2007 to allow dog owners adequate time to comply with the new requirements. However, owners of stray dogs that are impounded at a County shelter during the grace period will be required to comply immediately. After the grace period has ended, dog owners will be expected to be in compliance with this ordinance. Page 2 of 3 New Ordinance Introduction Page - Department of Animal Care & Control 2/10/2011 http://animalcare.lacounty.gov/cms1_045463.asp Attachment B - Page 5Fines and Penalties A first violation of this ordinance is an infraction punishable by a fine not to exceed $250. If the owner fails to correct the underlying cause of the violation within 30 days after being notified of the violation, it shall be deemed a second violation. A second violation is a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment in the county jail for a period not to exceed six months or by a fine not to exceed $1,000, or by both such fine and imprisonment. Each subsequent violation shall be considered an additional misdemeanor. The full text of this ordinance is available on our website. If you still want more information, please visit your local County shelter, write to us at 5898 Cherry Avenue, Long Beach, CA 90805, or e-mail us, using the link on our website homepage. You may also contact us by telephone at (562) 256-7104. Staff is available to assist you Monday through Thursday from 6:00 AM to 4:30 PM. FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS (FAQ’s) – Click on link below: Spay & Neuter FAQ’s Microchip FAQ’s Low Cost Services FAQ’s Registries and Breed Clubs FAQ’s License Fees FAQ’s Page 3 of 3 New Ordinance Introduction Page - Department of Animal Care & Control 2/10/2011 http://animalcare.lacounty.gov/cms1_045463.asp Attachment B - Page 6SUMMARY OF DOG PARK RULES RELATED TO CHILDREN AND SPAYING/NEUTERING OF DOGS 46 Entities - 24 are in California Require  License Require  Spay/Neuter Prohibit  Aggression Must Supervise  Children Prohibit  Children 1 Corona XX 2 Costa Mesa X XX 3 Foster City X XX 4 Huntington Beach-Best Friend DP XX 5 Irvine X XX 6 Laguna Beach X X 7 Long Beach X XX 8 Los Angeles-Sepulveda Basin DP X XX 9 Orange-Yorba Park X XX 10 Pasadena X 11 Rancho Cucamonga X XX 12 Redondo Beach X XX 13 Redwood City-Shore Dogs Park XX 14 Roseville X XX 15 Sacramento X XX 16 San Diego-Rancho Bernardo DP X XX 17 Santa Barbara County X XX 18 Santa Monica X X 19 Santee X 20 South San Francisco Bay Area X XX 21 Upland-Baldy View Dog Park X XX 22 Vacaville X XX X 23 Vellejo-Wardlaw Park X XX X 24 Westminster DP-Venice X X 1 Albuquerque, NM X XX X 2 Bellaire, TX X XX 3 Bismarck P&R District, ND X XX 4 Boone County, KY X XX 5 Burnsville, MN X XX 6 Cleveland, OH-Lakewood DP X XX 7 Dayton, OH X XX 8 Des Moines, IA-Raccoon River X X 9 Des Moines, IA-Windsor Heights X XX 10 Dorchester, MA-Ronan Park X XX 11 Fairfax County, VA X XX 12 Houston, TX X XX 13 Iowa City, IA X XX 14 Kingwood, TX XX 15 Phoenix, AZ X XX 16 Rarity Bay, TN XX 17 Reno, NV X XX 18 Satellite Beach, FL X XX 19 Seattle, WA X XX 20 St. Paul, MN X XX 21 Three Rivers Park District-MN XX 22 Tulsa, OK X XX X TOTAL 39 444 28 13 PERCENTAGE 85% 9% 96% 61% 28% Attachment B - Page 7REVIEW OF DOG PARK RULES RELATED TO CHILDREN AND SPAYING/NEUTERING OF DOGS No Reference 7 Required 39 TOTAL 46 No Reference 39 Recommended 3 Must Be Neutered 4 STOTAL 46 U M M No Reference 1 A Unknown 1 R Not Allowed 44 YTOTAL 46 No Reference 5 16 12 13 46 CITY / AREA SPAY/NEUTER AGGRESSION LANGUAGE RELATING TO CHILDREN Culver City - CURRENT (not  included in summary) No reference. Not allowed. Children twelve (12) years of age and under are not permitted in the Dog Park,  unless accompanied and supervised by an adult at all times. LICENSE REQUIRED SPAY/NEUTER AGGRESSIVE DOGS CHILDREN IN DOG PARKS Children Must Be Supervised Children of a Specified Age Must Be Supervised Children of a Specified Age Are Prohibited Page 1 of 7 Attachment B - Page 8REVIEW OF DOG PARK RULES RELATED TO CHILDREN AND SPAYING/NEUTERING OF DOGS CITY / AREA SPAY/NEUTER AGGRESSION LANGUAGE RELATING TO CHILDREN CALIFORNIA 1 Corona No reference. Not allowed. Children fourteen years of age and younger must be accompanied and supervised by a  person at least eighteen years of age while in a designated dog park area, and such  children are not permitted to run, shout, scream, wave their arms, or otherwise excite  or antagonize dogs in a designated dog park area.  2 Costa Mesa No reference. Not allowed. •MONITOR your child’s activities, if you bring young children to the dog park. Do not  put your children at risk •DOGS PLAY HARD running, tumbling, jumping, rassling – they are not looking out for  children and could knock them down, etc •NO RUNNING; a dog’s instinct is to chase a moving object and/or try to herd them by  nipping at the heels •NOISE; a screaming or crying child resembles an injured animal and will attract dogs  who could become excited and/or aggressive •APPROACHING UNKNOWN DOGS; while your dog may be accustomed to children, not  all dogs are – teach your children to wait for the owner’s permission and to let the dog  come to them •BALLS & DOG TOYS are dirty and belong to the dogs – teach your children to leave  them alone for health and safety reasons •NO CLIMBING on trees or fences •RECLAIMED WATER is used in the irrigation system & dog urine is present  everywhere, so keep small children from sitting on the ground or playing in standing  water 3 Foster City Spaying and  neutering  recommended. Not allowed. Supervise small children. 4 Huntington Beach-Best  Friend Dog Park No reference. Not allowed. CHILDREN UNDER 18 YEARS OF AGE MUST BE WITHIN ARM’S REACH OF A  SUPERVISING ADULT – This is a Dog Park, not a playground or daycare center. While  children are not prohibited, they are not particularly welcome because it’s NOT safe.  It’s not fair to responsible dog owners to have to worry about children who misbehave  or dogs who may not be used to active children. If you bring children into the Dog Park,  you must supervise them, keeping them within arm’s reach and totally under control. If  your children create problems for owners and their dogs, you will be asked to leave the  Dog Park.  5 Irvine No reference. Not allowed. This is a canine park, not a child's playground.  Toddlers are not allowed; other  children must be attended to at all times. Page 2 of 7 Attachment B - Page 9REVIEW OF DOG PARK RULES RELATED TO CHILDREN AND SPAYING/NEUTERING OF DOGS CITY / AREA SPAY/NEUTER AGGRESSION LANGUAGE RELATING TO CHILDREN 6 Laguna Beach No reference. Not allowed. No reference. 7 Long Beach No reference. Not allowed. Children must be supervised by adults.  Children are not permitted to run, shout,  scream, wave arms or excite or antagonize dogs.  8 Los Angeles-Sepulveda  Basin Dog Park (Encino) No reference. Not allowed. Small children must be closely supervised by an adult at all times. Please  discourage your child from running to minimize the chance of your child being  chased. 9 Orange-Yorba Park No reference. Not allowed. While inside the boundaries of any dog exercise area, an adult must accompany  minors under the age of sixteen (16). 10 Pasadena (MC) No reference. Not allowed. No reference. 11 Rancho Cucamonga No reference. Not allowed. No dog is permitted in the off-leash area except in the care, custody and control  of a person thirteen years or older.  Children twelve years of age and younger  must be supervised by an adult while in the off-leash area. 12 Redondo Beach No reference. Not allowed. Children under 12 must be closely supervised at all times by an adult. (It is urged  that young children not be brought to the Dog Park for their own health &  safety. They must be close enough to hold your hand at all times!) 13 Redwood City-Shore Dogs  Park No reference. Not allowed. This park is a designated "Dog Park". It is not intended as a children's playground. Dogs in the park can and will often assume "natural canine behavior" (run wildly while at play, etc.), which may not be a safe environment for small children. Shore Dogs Dog Club recommends that you don't bring small children into the park. Unaccompanied children are not allowed in the park --  you bring children at your own risk. 14 Roseville No reference. Not allowed. Children must be under supervision.  15 Sacramento No reference. Not allowed. Children less than 14 must be accompanied by an adult.  16 San Diego-Rancho  Bernardo Dog Park Spaying and  neutering of dogs  is recommended. Not allowed. Parents must closely supervise children. Parents must ask permission from the  dog owner for children to play with a dog. 17 Santa Barbara County No reference. Not allowed. Young children must be closely supervised. 18 Santa Monica No reference. Not allowed. No reference. 19 Santee No reference. No reference. No reference. Page 3 of 7 Attachment B - Page 10REVIEW OF DOG PARK RULES RELATED TO CHILDREN AND SPAYING/NEUTERING OF DOGS CITY / AREA SPAY/NEUTER AGGRESSION LANGUAGE RELATING TO CHILDREN 20 South San Francisco Bay  Area No reference. Not allowed. Don't leave kids unsupervised.  Small children should be very closely supervised,  or not brought to the park.  Understand there is an element of risk. 21 Upland-Baldy View Dog  Park No reference. Not allowed. POSTED RULE:  Children under the age of 12 years old must be accompanied and  supervised by an adult.  DOG PARK COURTESIES:  Special note to Parents - Please  understand that some dogs may be not be safe with your child. Small children  are easily run over and knocked down by running or playful dogs. Herding  breeds may nip children in an attempt to “round them up”. Some have strong  instincts to chase prey and may mistake a child for a small or injured animal.  Some dogs may jump high enough to investigate babies that are carried in baby  packs. 22 Vacaville Un-neutered  males over the  age of six (6)  months will not  be allowed inside  the park. Not allowed. Minor children must be accompanied by an adult. Parents should refrain from  bringing toddlers or small children into the park, unless they are willing to keep  the children out of harm’s way, totally under control and accept full  responsibility for their safety. Please remember this is a Dog Park and not a  playground for children. If your children create problems for owners and their  dogs, you may be asked by other participants to leave the Dog Park for safety’s  sake. Children should not run with the dogs or chase them while in the park. 23 Vellejo-Wardlaw Park All male dogs  entering this  park must be  neutered, no  female dogs in  heat allowed.  Not allowed. Children under 12 years of age must be accompanied and supervised by an adult  at all times. Adults with young children (ages 1-5) must keep their children  within an arm’s length. 24 Westminster Dog Park -  Venice No reference. Not allowed. No reference. Page 4 of 7 Attachment B - Page 11REVIEW OF DOG PARK RULES RELATED TO CHILDREN AND SPAYING/NEUTERING OF DOGS CITY / AREA SPAY/NEUTER AGGRESSION LANGUAGE RELATING TO CHILDREN OTHER STATES 1 Albuquerque, NM Un-neutered male  dogs and  female  dogs in heat shall  not be permitted  in the off-leash  dog exercise area. Not allowed. Children under the age of 12 are not allowed inside the off-leash dog exercise  area unless accompanied by an adult. Parents must refrain from bringing  toddlers and small children to the dog park and at no time be allowed to run  with, or chase after dogs in the park. 2 Bellaire, TX No reference. Not allowed. No children under age 12. 3 Bismarck Parks &  Recreation District, ND No reference. Not allowed. No children under 11 years of age on any field. Children under 11 may be in  the central corridor (not in dog "fields") if accompanied by an adult at all  times. 4 Boone County, KY No reference. Not allowed. No Children under the age of 16 is permitted unless accompanied by an adult.  Children have a tendency to scream and run when excited, which can trigger a  dog's prey drive or natural instinct to chase. For this reason and for the safety of  your children, we do not recommend bringing small children and infants into the  dog park.  5 Burnsville, MN No reference. Not allowed. For their safety, supervise children inside the park at all times. 6 Cleveland, OH-Lakewood  Dog Park No reference. Not allowed. Children under the age of 16 shall not be permitted in the park without adult  supervision. It is not recommended that small children visit the inside of the  park. 7 Dayton, OH No reference. Not allowed. All children must be monitored and accompanied by a guardian at all times. 8 Des Moines, IA-Raccoon  River No reference. Unknown. Raccoon River does not allow any children under age 11 (quoted from email).  9 Des Moines, IA-Windsor  Heights No reference. Not allowed. All children under 13 years old must be accompanied by an adult and parents  must supervise small children closely at all times. Page 5 of 7 Attachment B - Page 12REVIEW OF DOG PARK RULES RELATED TO CHILDREN AND SPAYING/NEUTERING OF DOGS CITY / AREA SPAY/NEUTER AGGRESSION LANGUAGE RELATING TO CHILDREN 10 Dorchester, MA-Ronan Park No reference. Not allowed. This is a playground for dogs, not children.Children under age 7 are not allowed  in the DRS, and children ages 7-13 must be supervised by an adult. Be sure you  teach your child how to behave properly in a DRS. Children should not run  around, scream, pick up and wave sticks, or approach animals that they do not  know. 11 Fairfax County, VA No reference. Not allowed. Children 8 years and under are not allowed in the off-leash dog area; children  ages 9 - 15 years must be accompanied by an adult.  Handlers must be 16 years of age or older.  12 Houston, TX No reference. Not allowed. No children age 12 or younger are allowed in the Dog Park.  Children ages 13  through 18 must be accompanied by an adult. Permitted children must be  supervised by the adult and behave appropriately: No running, shouting, chasing  dogs, or petting other people’s dogs without the owner’s permission. 13 Iowa City, IA No reference. Not allowed. All dogs must be accompanied by a responsible person at least 16 years old.   Children under the age of 16 must be accompanied and supervised by a  responsible adult.  14 Kingwood, TX No reference. Not allowed. Children under 9 are not permitted in the park.  It is strongly urged that young  children not be brought to the park for their own safety. 15 Phoenix, AZ To discourage  aggressive  behavior, the city  of Phoenix  recommends that  dog owners only  bring animals that  have been spayed  or neutered.  Not allowed. Some dogs exhibit unpredictable behavior around small children. For the  safety of children please do not bring children under the age of 12 into the dog  parks. 16 Rarity Bay, TN No reference. Not allowed. No children under age 12 may be inside the Park. An adult must accompany  and constantly supervise all minors under age 18 while inside the Park. Page 6 of 7 Attachment B - Page 13REVIEW OF DOG PARK RULES RELATED TO CHILDREN AND SPAYING/NEUTERING OF DOGS CITY / AREA SPAY/NEUTER AGGRESSION LANGUAGE RELATING TO CHILDREN 17 Reno, NV No reference. Not allowed. Children must be accompanied at all times by a responsible adult.  Children should be  discouraged from approaching or playing with strange dogs. 18 Satellite Beach, FL No reference. Not allowed. NO - Too many children and dogs to properly supervise.  (One adult to supervise  several children, an infant, and the family dog is not enough. Make sure you can take  care of every creature you bring into the park.) 19 Seattle, WA No reference. Not allowed. You must closely supervise young children.  20 St. Paul, MN No reference. Not allowed. It is recommended that children be supervised by a parent or guardian. 21 Three Rivers Park District- MN No reference. Not allowed. Children must be closely supervised by adults and should be instructed about  proper behavior around dogs. 22 Tulsa, OK No dog more than  six (6) months old  which has not  been spayed or neutered shall be  permitted within  an off-leash dog  park. Not allowed. No person under 16 years of age shall be permitted to bring a dog into an off-leash park area. For safety reasons, children must be at least 12 years old and supervised by an adult to use the dog park. Children must behave in a responsible manner: no running, chasing dogs, or petting dogs without the owner's permission. The Dog Park is not a petting zoo or a place to “get the child over his/her fear of dogs.” While most dogs are curious and friendly, not all dogs are  child-friendly. Some have strong prey-chasing instincts and may mistake a baby for a small, injured creature. A running, screaming child attracts  attention and becomes a target for many dogs, because the child resembles an injured animal or running prey. Herding breeds may nip children in an  attempt to round them up. Children are just the right height to make direct eye contact with dogs, placing them at great risk from dogs which  consider this a confrontational challenge. Children are easily run over and knocked down by running or playful dogs. Dogs can jump high enough to  investigate babies in front- and backpacks. Children may pick up fleas and may contract intestinal parasites where dog urine and feces are present.  If you still decide to bring your child into the Dog Park—which you do at your own risk—please observe these safety precautions: Do not allow your  child to wildly wave his/her arms around. Do not allow your child to run and scream. Do not allow your child to play with toys in the park. Do not  allow your child to approach or pet a dog without the owner's presence and permission. Before coming to the park, teach your child what experts  suggest in an emergency situation: Never run. Hide face, fold arms, and stand still “like a tree”; or lie down, tuck arms and legs into the body, and lie  still “like a log.” Wait until the dog leaves or help arrives.  WARNING: The Dog Park is NOT a safe place for children. Therefore, it is strongly urged that small children not be brought into the park. The Dog  Park was created as a place for people to enjoy their dogs off-leash. There are plenty of other parks where children can safely play and socialize. Page 7 of 7 Attachment B - Page 14  Maintenance: 310-253-6470 Report a Problem: 310-837-1221   SPECIAL NOTE TO DOG OWNERS: “The person who has charge, care, custody or control of any dog must ensure the dog is currently licensed, vaccinated and over the age of four (4) months, and provide proof of licensing upon request by any City official” (CCMC § 9.10.400.A.1). Culver City Dog Licensing Requirements: The City of Culver City requires that all dogs over the age of four (4) months have a current license (CCMC § 9.01.500; Los Angeles County Code (“LACC”) § 10.20.030) and that the license tag must be worn at all times (CCMC §§ 9.01.400.A.1 and 9.01.500; LACC § 10.20.180). To obtain a license, owners must show proof that their dog: To apply for a new license or to renew your current license, please go to www.PetData.com and select “Culver City.” You may also contact 1-888-615-4350 for further information. THANK YOU Has a current rabies vaccination. Has been spayed or neutered. Has been microchipped. (NOTE: ACTUAL SIGN WILL BE 11” WIDE BY 17” HIGH) ATTACHMENT C Page 15Maintena   SPECIA and und and sup • Adults within • Childr park. • Durin out o behav S S p H S c S c (NO ance: 310 AL NOTE der are n pervised “Superv s with yo n arm’s le ren shou g each v f harm’s vior: Some do Small chi playful do Herding b Some do child for a Some do carried in OTE: AC 0-253-647 E TO PA not perm d by an a vised by oung ch ength at uld not r visit to th s way – gs may n ldren are ogs. breeds m gs have a small o ogs may j n baby pa CTUAL S 70 ARENTS mitted in adult at a y an adu hildren (a all times run with he park, remem not be sa e easily ru may nip ch strong in r injured jump hig acks. SIGN WIL THAN R S: “Child n the Do all times” ult at all ages 1 – s. the dog it is you ber the fe with yo un over a hildren in stincts to animal. h enoug ILL BE 1 NK YOU Report a dren twe og Park, ” (CCMC times” m – 5) mus s or cha r obligat followin our child. and knock an attem o chase p h to inve 11” WIDE Problem elve (12) unless Section means: st keep ase them ion to ke g facts . ked down mpt to “ro prey and estigate b E BY 17 : 310-837 years o accomp 9.10.40 their ch m while i eep your about c n by runn und them may mist babies th 7” HIGH) 7-1221 of age panied 00.B). ildren in the r child canine ning or m up”. take a at are ATTACHMENT D Page 16